Why a Written RFP Beats a Round of Demos
You're about to pick a company that will legally employ your people in countries where you have no entity. It will sign their contracts, run their payroll, hold their data and handle their terminations. A demo shows you the dashboard. The real risk sits where demos never go: who owns the local entity, who pays a tax penalty, and what it costs to leave.
A structured employer of record RFP makes every vendor answer the same questions in writing, so you can compare line by line. It also gives you something a sales deck doesn't: written statements you can attach to the contract as exhibits. Vendors tend to be more careful with a claim that could become a contractual warranty than with one made on a call.
The playbook below runs from shortlist to signature. The 40 questions are grouped by risk area, and each group lists the answers that should count as red flags. For most companies hiring in three to ten countries, a full employer of record RFP takes roughly six to ten weeks.
| Stage | Typical duration | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Requirements and scoring model | 1 week | Country list, headcount plan, weighted criteria |
| Longlist to shortlist | 1 week | 3 to 4 vendors invited |
| Written responses | 2 weeks | Answers to all 40 questions, sample documents |
| Security review and reference calls | 1 to 2 weeks | Completed security questionnaire, 2 or 3 references per vendor |
| Commercial negotiation | 1 to 2 weeks | Pricing, SLA credits, exit terms |
| Legal review and signature | 1 to 2 weeks | Master agreement plus country schedules |
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
Fix the Scoring Model Before Any Vendor Sees a Question
Buyers who write the scoring model after reading responses usually pick the best-written answer, not the best one. Settle your EOR provider evaluation criteria first.
- List your countries and headcount for the next 18 months. Your future footprint matters more than your current one. A vendor that's strong in Western Europe may rely entirely on partners in West Africa or Central America.
- Weight the risk areas. A reasonable default: entity and legal model 20%, payroll accuracy 20%, data security 15%, pricing 15%, benefits 10%, SLAs and support 10%, exit terms 10%. Raise security if you handle regulated data. Raise benefits if you compete hard for senior talent.
- Score every answer from 0 to 3. 0 means missing or evasive; 3 means specific and documented. Any red-flag answer scores zero and must be fixed in the contract, or the vendor drops out.
- Shortlist three or four vendors. A typical shortlist mixes large platforms such as Deel, Remote, Rippling or Oyster with a regional or specialist provider that is strong in your hardest country.
- Require written answers and sample documents. A link to a marketing page isn't an answer.
Hypothetical example: say a 35-person software company plans 14 hires across Poland, India, Brazil, the Philippines and Kenya. Its weighting should lean toward entity ownership and payroll accuracy. Brazil and the Philippines carry mandatory 13th-month pay, India carries provident fund and gratuity obligations, and Kenya coverage varies a lot between vendors.
Entity Ownership and Legal Model: Questions 1 to 7
This area has the highest stakes and the most marketing spin. Every vendor claims global coverage, but far fewer own an entity in every country they list.
- Q1. For each of our target countries, do you own the local entity, or do you work through an in-country partner?
- Q2. Where a partner is used, who signs the employment contract, who holds the payroll and tax registration, and what's your contractual relationship with that partner?
- Q3. How long has each entity or partner operated in that country, and when was it last audited?
- Q4. How do you secure IP assignment, and will you sign a back-to-back assignment so work product passes from the employee through you to us?
- Q5. What guidance do you give on permanent establishment risk, and which activities by our staff (signing contracts, closing sales) would you advise against?
- Q6. Walk us through a termination in a protective jurisdiction such as Germany, France, the Netherlands, Brazil or India: who advises, who negotiates, and who pays severance?
- Q7. What liability caps and indemnities do you offer for compliance errors and misclassification, and what insurance stands behind them?
Red flags: no per-country list of owned versus partner entities. Refusal to explain the partner relationship. IP assigned to the EOR with no onward assignment to you. Indemnity capped at one or two months of fees, which is unlikely to cover a single contested dismissal in many European or Latin American countries.
Payroll Accuracy and Statutory Compliance: Questions 8 to 14
Employees notice payroll errors first. Statutory errors cost more later, because tax and social-security authorities can charge interest and penalties for years afterward.
- Q8. What's the payroll cutoff in each country, how are off-cycle runs handled, and what do they cost?
- Q9. Provide a sample payslip and a full employer-cost breakdown for one role in each of our countries.
- Q10. How do you track statutory changes such as minimum wage, contribution ceilings and tax bands, and how quickly do they reach payroll?
- Q11. Who files statutory returns, and will you provide proof of remittance for tax, social security and pension contributions on request?
- Q12. How do you measure payroll accuracy, and who pays penalties and interest caused by your errors?
- Q13. How do you calculate and accrue mandatory extras, such as 13th-month pay in the Philippines and Brazil, Mexico's aguinaldo and PTU profit sharing, and end-of-service gratuity in India and the UAE?
- Q14. What currency are employees paid in, who sets the exchange rate, and when is it locked?
Red flags: unwillingness to show proof of remittance. Penalty liability described as "case by case." Employer-cost estimates that omit mandatory accruals, which can make a vendor look materially cheaper than it really is in some Latin American and Asian markets.
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
Benefits and Employee Experience: Questions 15 to 20
Your employees will deal with the EOR more often than you will, so a weak benefits setup becomes a retention problem. Statutory benefits vary widely. Some countries rely mostly on state health systems; others expect private cover from the employer. Pension rules range from UK auto-enrolment to Australian superannuation to India's provident fund.
- Q15. For each country, which benefits are statutory, which supplemental plans do you offer, and which are included in the base fee?
- Q16. Who is the insurer or broker for supplemental health cover, and can we review the plan documents before signing?
- Q17. Can we add employer pension top-ups or allowances above the statutory minimum, and how are they taxed locally?
- Q18. Can employees hold our equity, and do you handle local tax reporting and withholding when options vest or are exercised?
- Q19. Who tracks statutory leave, sick pay and parental leave, and can we apply our own more generous policy?
- Q20. What languages, hours and response times does your employee support offer?
Red flags: a single "global plan" offered as if it met every local requirement. No process for equity tax reporting. Employee support only in English and only during one region's working hours.
Data Security: Questions 21 to 27 for Your EOR Security Questionnaire
Send your standard security questionnaire (a SIG Lite or CAIQ-style assessment works), then add these EOR-specific questions. An EOR holds national ID numbers, bank details, salaries and sometimes health data, and that data often sits with in-country partners your normal review never covers. Buyers skip this part of EOR vendor due diligence more than any other.
- Q21. Which certifications do you hold (for example SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001), and does their scope cover in-country partners or only your platform?
- Q22. Where is employee data stored and processed, and can you share your current subprocessor list?
- Q23. Which cross-border transfer mechanisms do you use under GDPR, the UK regime, Brazil's LGPD, India's DPDP Act and similar laws?
- Q24. For each data set, who is the controller and who is the processor?
- Q25. How many hours after discovering a breach will you notify us?
- Q26. Do you support SSO, role-based access and audit logs, so managers can't see salaries outside their own teams?
- Q27. How do you retain and delete data at contract end, given that statutory retention periods differ by country?
Red flags: certifications that cover the software but not the partners who run payroll. No subprocessor list. Breach notification promised "without undue delay" with no hour commitment. Ask for a specific number; 24 to 72 hours is a common range, though some laws set their own deadlines for you.
SLAs, Exit and Transfer Terms: Questions 28 to 34
Exit terms are your leverage if service slips. Read the termination and transfer clauses as closely as the pricing.
- Q28. What does your EOR service level agreement commit to on on-time payroll, onboarding time and support response, and what service credits apply when you miss?
- Q29. What's the realistic time from signed offer to employment start in each country, including any work-permit steps?
- Q30. Will we have a named account manager, and what's the escalation path for a payroll failure?
- Q31. What's the notice period to end the master agreement and to offboard a single employee?
- Q32. If we transfer employees to our own entity or to another EOR, what fees apply?
- Q33. Will you hand over contracts, payroll history and accrued balances, and cooperate with the transfer within a stated number of days?
- Q34. Do any non-solicitation or buyout clauses restrict us from employing our own staff directly?
In much of Europe, a transfer can trigger acquired-rights rules that preserve length of service and terms of employment. Have local counsel confirm how a move would work in each country before you sign.
Red flags: transfer fees calculated as a percentage of salary. SLAs with no credits attached. Twelve-month lock-ins that auto-renew. Any clause that charges you for hiring someone who already works for you.
Pricing Questions and the Path to Signature: Questions 35 to 40
Vendors structure quotes in ways that are hard to compare. Ask for every cost line in the same format.
- Q35. What's the all-in monthly fee per employee in each country, and what's excluded?
- Q36. How much is the security deposit, where is it held, and when is it refunded? Do you offer a deposit waiver?
- Q37. What FX margin applies to our funding and to employee payouts?
- Q38. What one-time fees apply to onboarding, contract amendments, off-cycle runs, termination and offboarding?
- Q39. What cap applies to price increases at renewal?
- Q40. What discounts apply for volume or annual prepayment?
| Cost line | Typical 2026 market range | What to push for |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly EOR fee, owned-entity markets | $400 to $700 per employee | Annual-commitment pricing listed per country |
| Monthly EOR fee, complex or partner markets | $700 to $1,200+ per employee | Written confirmation of the partner model |
| Security deposit | Often 0 to 3 months of employer cost | Refund within 30 days of offboarding, or a waiver |
| FX margin | 0.5% to 3% | Margin stated in the contract, not "market rate" |
| Off-cycle payroll run | Roughly $50 to $250 per run | A set number of free runs per year |
| Offboarding or termination fee | $0 to $1,000+ per employee | Waived for transfers to your own entity |
| Renewal increase | Often 3% to 8% per year | A contractual cap |
These are indicative ranges. They vary by country, contract size and commitment length, so confirm current figures with each vendor. Have local counsel and a tax adviser review the final terms in your highest-risk countries.
To finish the employer of record RFP, total the weighted scores, then run reference calls with customers in your hardest country, not your easiest. Attach the winning vendor's written answers to Q1, Q11, Q12, Q25, Q28 and Q32 to the contract as exhibits. Then apply this rule: if no vendor scores at least 2 out of 3 on entity ownership and payroll accuracy, don't let price decide. Split countries between two providers instead.